Jaal eZine TOC Jaal eZine - desi satire         desi satire Jaal eZine TOC
I'm not going trekking in the Himalayas with Yashwant Sinha
'Coz he hangs out with dolts, says Paranjoy Guha Thakurta

Slang Match Slang Match

Has the sexual revolution come to India?
Fair Game Fair Game

And the Greatest of the Best Ever Award goes to... Jaal
Laughing Stock Laughing Stock

The Ten Faces of Budgetmaker Sinha
Smear Scape Smear Scape

Sushma Swaraj + Pakistan = Lots of Cakes
Calumny Column Calumny Cloumn

Go Man Go!! JB Shown the door
HateEmail HATe-mail

Spins & Needles Spins & Needles
 
 
Paranjoy
Yashwant Sinha is not exactly my kind of guy. Not that I have anything against former bureaucrats, especially those who have served in the country's biggest loss-making organisation (the Delhi Transport Corporation). Nor do I have any special disdain for former officials who choose a career in politics. For that matter, nor do I have strong negative feelings about politicians who switch sides as Sinha did when he stopped being the right-hand man of our left-wing former Prime Minister Chandra Shekhar (who pawned the country's gold abroad because our dear non-resident Indian friends had panicked and withdrawn their deposits) and instead became the left-handed supporter of right-wing Hindu nationalist Prime Minister Atal Behari Vajpayee. And, to be absolutely certain, I do not have any reason to malign men with thin moustaches.

The question then naturally arises as to why I am not particularly enamoured about the Honourable Finance Minister of Bharat. To be fair to him, fired by the spirit of swadeshi, Sinha has done all a great favour by deciding to present the Union Budget for 1999-2000 on Saturday, 27 February, at 11.00 am. Thus, more than fifty years after Independence, he has rid the country of one more relic of the colonial past: the unsavoury convention of presenting Budgets at 5.00 pm when the markets in London would open.

The question remains as to why I don't think Yashwant Sinha is the kind of guy with whom I would like to go on a long trek to the Himalayas. Take this year's Budget. He's already told the entire nation that it would be a "hard" budget not a "harsh" one. Soon thereafter, he went ahead and increased the officially administered prices of rice, wheat, sugar and urea. Sinha's Cabinet colleagues and coalition partners screamed blue murder and within a few days, the government had once again not only established its pro-poor credentials but also sent out a message loud and clear to the country at large that the "roll-back" prefix attached to the Finance Minister's name was there for a good reason. Just because Sinha rolled back the prices of urea, petrol and customs duty last June, you thought he would not do it again. What can I say? Lily, you are indeed so silly; I thought you were hotter than a red chilly.

main story pic One good aspect about all these nasty price hikes is that the sooner they are got over with, the better. That way, the Budget looks better. It appears Sinha has picked up a tip or two from former Finance Ministers (like Narayan Datt Tiwari, "na nar, na nari") who did exactly what he has done and then, reduced taxes on kajal and kum-kum to show how much he favoured empowerment of women. It is hardly surprising then that sections of the extended Sangh parivar are most upset with people like Vajpayee and Sinha who are appearing like Congressmen in disguise. Given the heat generated by the fire-breathing saffron brigade, Sinha's advocacy of "calibrated" liberalisation may go down well in Davos (Switzerland) but not in Dangs district (Gujarat).

Not very long ago, Sinha had bitterly complained at a press conference that he was the most maligned Finance Minister India ever had. To be fair to him, he has also been the most transparent FM. Barely three weeks before the presentation of the Budget, he inaugurated the Finance Ministry's new website and placed on it important facts and figures about the profligate ways of the government. Thanks to his generosity, the whole world now knows that the country's revenue deficit had gone up threefold in the first three quarters of the current financial year. Isn't that a nice thing for the FM to do?

That is, make it all public well in advance so that people do not have wait till Budget day to start moaning and groaning.

Sinha is different in at least one important respect from all previous Indian Finance Ministers. Nearly one month before that dull, boring document is read out in front of television cameras, he has already informed all that matter what the main features of the Budget would be.

Ladies and gentlemen, hear hear! The cumbersome excise duty structure would be rationalised by reducing the number of tax slabs, the list of items eligible for zero-duty import would be cut drastically, the anomaly between the capital gains tax rates applicable to Indians and foreigners would be removed to provide the proverbial level playing field, thereby sending stockmarkets soaring skywards.... have I forgotten something? Well, maybe.

The point I'm making is actually quite simple. The reason why Sinha is not exactly my favourite guy is because he appears to be a nice fellow in the company of downright dolts. A friend of mine who (stupid fellow) hung himself to death, once called me a hard-working fool. Since then, I've begun disliking anyone who remotely fits into that category. Now you know why I love to hate Yashwant Sinha.

Illustration by Siddhartha Mitra


Paranjoy anchors "India Talks", CNBC Asia television's current-affairs interview and discussion programme.

| About Us | Archives | Help | E-mail | Advertise | Legal Crap | Webmaster |
Copyright © 1999 Jaal eZine™ Designed & Hosted by [ iNetSol INDIA ]